Real Job Openings or Data Collection Mechanisms? The Unresolved Debate About LinkedIn and “Ghost Jobs”
Let’s talk about something many of us have struggled with: looking for a job.

A few years ago, I set myself the goal of working for an international company in my favorite field: personal data protection. LinkedIn seemed like the main route to getting there.
The routine was familiar: search for vacancies, fill out forms, upload a résumé, tailor the application, and wait. A cycle that takes time, raises expectations, and involves sharing a great deal of personal information.
Over time, I noticed that several companies kept advertising the same positions. One remote privacy role, in particular, kept reappearing for more than a year.
One possible explanation is the creation of a talent pool: a database of candidates for future recruitment, even when there is no immediate position to fill. And that raises a question: are we taking part in a recruitment process, or in an ongoing mechanism for collecting personal data?
Of course, repeated job postings can have legitimate explanations, such as growth, employee turnover, or the search for specialized expertise. But when a position stays open for months or years with no apparent conclusion, it is reasonable to ask what happens to those applications.
Applicants expect to take part in a genuine, current recruitment process. If the purpose is to retain their profiles for future opportunities, they should know that. This is the heart of the debate: transparency about why our data is collected, how it is used, and how long it is kept.
What Role Does LinkedIn Play?
LinkedIn provides a legitimate platform for connecting professionals with job opportunities. Recruitment intermediation is part of its business model, and there is, in principle, nothing wrong with companies advertising vacancies on the platform.
However, precisely because it facilitates that interaction, it is also reasonable to ask what mechanisms exist to detect misleading, fraudulent, or potentially abusive postings.
The issue is not whether LinkedIn creates the job postings, but whether it should have certain due diligence obligations when it has enough information to identify unusual patterns. Examples include identical vacancies advertised over long periods, the same position being repeatedly reopened, recruitment processes accumulating thousands of applications, and companies maintaining recurring job postings with no visible evidence of hiring.
The Precedent Set by Digital Platforms
In Europe, the debate over platform responsibility has evolved considerably.
Airbnb offers an illustrative example. European authorities have questioned whether the measures implemented to prevent misleading listings or potentially fraudulent information are sufficient. The discussion focuses not only on who creates the content, but also on what steps the platform takes to reduce foreseeable risks to users.
In LinkedIn’s case, the harm would not necessarily be financial, as it might be when someone books accommodation that does not exist. The risk could be different: the large-scale collection of personal data under the guise of recruitment.
Data Protection and Responsibility
When applications are submitted directly through LinkedIn’s tools, the discussion becomes particularly interesting. The platform determines certain aspects of the processing: it structures forms, defines fields, establishes submission procedures, and stores and organizes candidate information.
This raises the question of how far it participates in determining the means of processing.
By contrast, when the entire application process takes place on the employer’s website, LinkedIn appears to act primarily as an intermediary directing traffic to a third party. Even in that scenario, however, a separate question remains: the due diligence obligations applicable to digital platforms.
An Open Question
Perhaps the question is not whether LinkedIn is automatically responsible for every misleading job posting on its platform.
The real question may be this:
Should a platform with millions of users implement mechanisms to detect persistently open or potentially fictitious vacancies when those postings could facilitate the large-scale collection of personal data?
This debate brings together data protection, digital transparency, and platform responsibility. And in a world where our résumés contain valuable professional, academic, and personal information, it is probably a conversation we still need to have.
Article provided by INPLP member: Emely Garcia (datalawrd, Dominican Republic)
